The AI Value Gap is an Operating Problem

More than half (52%) of everything our clients ask us about at Catalant involves AI. That’s a significant increase; compared to just one year ago, eight times as many companies now cite AI as a priority.
Clients who were previously focused on AI risk and readiness are now focused on transformation and adoption. AI has transitioned from the innovation agenda to the operating agenda, and leaders are looking to close the gap between the investments they have made and the impact they can show.
To understand that gap, we looked at more than 6,600 data points from more than 900 Fortune 500 and private equity-backed companies, gathered between August 2025 and September 2026. This data reflects live initiatives and active barriers stalling their progress.
The Cause of the Value Gap
Four barriers to AI value realization have dominated the conversations we’ve had over the past year, and companies often report several at once:
- 53% have no clear AI roadmap tied to their organizational or functional strategy and their team’s capacity to execute.
- 52% struggle to integrate AI with existing systems, including challenges from legacy incompatibility and fragmented data environments.
- 39% report ineffective change management, which leads to limited adoption, resistance, and no tangible shift in how people do their jobs day to day.
- 34% lack the in-house AI expertise needed to deliver significant change.
Notably, that last figure isn’t just about technical knowledge. Companies also lack experts who can clearly articulate what’s possible and the level of effort required to deliver impact, an understanding that requires both AI knowledge and business judgment.
Now, let’s consider the items at the bottom of the barriers list. Poor data readiness came in at 24%. Unclear success metrics at 11%. Immature governance and difficulty scaling pilots to production each landed at 7%. Those are all prominent factors in a lot of AI discussions, yet they don’t show up nearly as often when leaders are talking about the challenges they’re actively working to solve.
The barriers seem to cluster at two points: before anything gets built, where strategy and roadmap are missing, and after it ships, where adoption either happens or doesn’t.
What Today’s Leaders Need
For a long time, hiring a big legacy consulting firm was how a company showed it had dealt with a problem. With AI, that’s no longer the case. Now, boards are looking for visible results in the metrics and in the way work gets done. The engagement itself is no longer enough.
One clear sign these consulting engagements aren’t working anymore is that nearly 44% of the companies in our dataset had already worked with a major consulting firm before they came to Catalant for help with AI. For those companies, the most common barrier they reported was still the missing roadmap, one grounded in strategy and in what their organization can realistically carry out.
Those companies didn’t lack advice. They lacked a plan written by people who had run the function before and a team to lead them through the hard part.
How Delivery Has to Change
The barriers above point to the need for a different approach to doing AI work. It starts with the business outcomes that matter and works back to where AI makes the difference. This requires both a deep understanding of the function or business being changed and technical knowledge about how AI works and what it’s capable of.
That’s why we developed the Catalant Forward Deployed Experts™ (FDX) solution, which combines functional judgment and AI expertise to drive AI initiatives from start to finish. We listened to what clients told us was holding them back: the missing connection between an AI idea and the way the business actually runs.
When that’s the gap, more technology is rarely the answer. The wisdom of operators who have done this work before is.
Learn More About FDXAbout the Data
This data was originally published in September 2026 as part of Catalant Launches Forward Deployed Experts to Close the Gap Between AI Strategy and Business Impact.
Findings are based on Catalant’s analysis of more than 6,600 anonymized data points about how clients are working, gathered between August 2025 and September 2026 across our private equity and enterprise client base, classified by topic, industry, and client segment. Because the findings come from data points that reflect the active priorities of executives pursuing AI initiatives, rather than surveys, they offer a direct view of how companies are actually approaching AI.
Enterprise AI investments fail to produce measurable value mainly because of operating gaps, not technology gaps. Catalant analyzed more than 6,600 data points from over 900 Fortune 500 and private equity-backed companies and found that 53% lack an AI roadmap tied to strategy and execution capacity, and 52% struggle with systems integration. Barriers cluster before build (in strategy) and after deployment (in change management and adoption).
The four most common barriers are a missing AI roadmap (53%), difficulty integrating AI with existing systems (52%), ineffective change management (39%), and insufficient in-house AI expertise (34%). Companies often report several at once. Barriers such as data readiness (24%), unclear success metrics (11%), immature governance (7%), and scaling pilots to production (7%) appear far less often among key challenges cited by clients, per Catalant data.
Traditional consulting engagements deliver advice but often not executable plans. In Catalant data, nearly 44% of companies had already engaged a major consulting firm before seeking AI help, and the most common barrier for those companies remained a missing roadmap grounded in strategy and realistic organizational capacity. Boards now evaluate AI programs on visible results in metrics and ways of working, not on the engagement itself.
Enterprises need functional judgment and AI expertise combined, because 34% of companies cite a lack of in-house AI expertise, including experts who can explain what is possible and the effort required. Effective delivery starts with the business outcomes that matter and works back to where AI creates impact. Catalant’s Forward Deployed Experts solution combines operator experience with AI knowledge to lead initiatives from start to finish.
Enterprise AI initiatives most often stall at two points: before anything is built, when strategy and roadmap are missing, and after deployment, when user adoption either occurs or does not. Catalant data shows 53% of companies lack a roadmap and 39% report ineffective change management, which limits adoption and leaves daily work unchanged. Closing the AI value gap therefore requires operating discipline at both ends.
Related Articles
Share Article